Who Killed Christopher Goodman? by Allan Wolf

who killed

Originally published in: 2017

What it’s about: A fictionalized account of a 1979 murder that took place in the author’s hometown while he was in high school. Told through 6 different narrators – including the killer.

What made me pick it up: I was intrigued by the plot, but when I realized it was based on a real murder from my hometown’s past I knew I had to read it.

My favorite things: Wolf changed the name of the town and the people involved, but he kept the names of streets, events, and local businesses. For a native of the town where the murder occurred, reading this was a bizarre experience but still engaging. I love the variety of voices, used to paint a more complete picture of the events that took place, with each of the narrators trying to discover ways they could have prevented the senseless murder.

Who it’s great for: Older teens and adults who crave mysteries or suspense. The short chapters and rotating narration make this a great choice for reluctant readers.

Abby’s rating: three-and-a-half-shells


Pick up a copy of this book at Amazon (affiliate link) or in your local library.

We Have Always Lived in the Castle by Shirley Jackson

wehavealways

Originally published in: 1962

What it’s about: Merricat, Constance, and Uncle Julian are an odd, reclusive family, ostracized by the people of their community after the rest of their family die of arsenic poisoning.

What made me pick it up: This was a deep dive into my TBR backlist, but the audiobook was available on OverDrive so I went for it.

My favorite things: This isn’t a complex story, but it is elegantly told. Merricat’s narration is simple, uncomfortably direct, and quietly unsettling. And yet – her fears and anxieties feel valid and worthy of consideration. More sinister than odd, the Blackwood family still demands pity. Jackson was a master at creating creepy but believably human characters.

Who it’s great for: I don’t know about you, but when I’m in a reading slump, or really any kind of slump, I need a creepy story or two to kick me back into gear. If that’s true for you then you should definitely grab this the next time you need a pick-me-up. Good for fans of gothic novels, horror, and mysteries.

Abby’s rating: four-and-a-half-shells

merricat


Want a copy? Find one at Amazon (affiliate link) or see if it’s available at a library near you.


A Study in Charlotte by Brittany Cavallaro (2016)

23272028

What it’s about: A modern Sherlock Holmesian story, where the Holmes character is actually his teenage great-great-great-granddaughter Charlotte who happens to meet and partner with teen great-great-great-grandson of Watson (also Watson) to solve the murder mystery they stumble upon.

What made me pick it up: I discovered this when someone put in a request for similar books in our online reader’s advisory service. It sounded great once I realized it wasn’t a typo so I checked it right out.

My favorite things: This book is a true caper and sucks you in from the beginning. I thoroughly enjoyed going along with these characters and discovering  details as Watson did (Holmes is always many steps ahead). I liked the juxtaposition of Holmes being a woman and the thoughtful incorporation of Holmesian vices in a teenage landscape. A planned trilogy, I’m looking forward to the next book in this series.

Who it’s great for: Teens or adults. Anyone willing to suspend disbelief and turn in for a very entertaining jaunt.

Erica’s Rating: four-shells